Your comments make it obvious you have never ridden a modern Poo. If you weren't stupidly brand loyal and rode one...you'd want one.I'd rather have a sled that I run out of skill before the sled is overmatched. Some guys like Dickhaven get off on straightening out after a slight bend and be able to dangle the skis and feel like a boss. And that's fine by me.
Do I think Cat should do that? Well I'm not interested in anything like that so I'd say no. I could just ride my h.c. on the trail if I wanted to do that.