Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Advice 600 E-Tec or new 1200 4 Stroke
HCS Snowmobile Forums > Snowmobile Forums > Ski-Doo General Discussion > XP/XR New Style MXZ
patg85
I currently have a 2007 blizzard 600 sdi and I want to reserve my sled for next year. I am not sure which one I should go with. I like the light weight but to me I think the 4 stroke in the long term will be better in terms of reliability and resale value. I think as well as the overall cost, no oil better gas mileage.. I am not a fan of the 800 althought if they came out with a E-Tec version I would have taken that for sure... Anyway any opinions?
Charles
QUOTE(patg85 @ Mar 6 2008, 08:20 AM) *
I currently have a 2007 blizzard 600 sdi and I want to reserve my sled for next year. I am not sure which one I should go with. I like the light weight but to me I think the 4 stroke in the long term will be better in terms of reliability and resale value. I think as well as the overall cost, no oil better gas mileage.. I am not a fan of the 800 althought if they came out with a E-Tec version I would have taken that for sure... Anyway any opinions?



I could be wrong, but I believe the e-tec is actually supposed to get better mileage than the 4-tec. As far as oil, you will probably spend less on 2-stroke oil than oil changes on the 4-tec. Weight is definitely in favour of the e-tec. Reliability? Who knows! Has Skidoo got their act together and done their homework on the e-tec? Only time will tell. They sure are betting heavy on it though! The 4-stroke may outlast the 2-stroke in the long run, but unless you are planing to keep your new sled for 10+ years, that shouldn't be a concern. The near zero maintenance and light weight of the e-tec sure is appealing to me!
sledgehammer
yeah the e-tec will be better on fuel and oil cost is almost a non-issue now... the 4-tec will be heavier but have more power. dont think you could go wrong with either. e-tec is around 70-80 pounds lighter though.
FLsledder
What type of oil is recommended for the Etech?
jds800Rev
QUOTE(patg85 @ Mar 6 2008, 08:20 AM) *
I currently have a 2007 blizzard 600 sdi and I want to reserve my sled for next year. I am not sure which one I should go with. I like the light weight but to me I think the 4 stroke in the long term will be better in terms of reliability and resale value. I think as well as the overall cost, no oil better gas mileage.. I am not a fan of the 800 althought if they came out with a E-Tec version I would have taken that for sure... Anyway any opinions?


I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!
Trail Ryder
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 12:31 PM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!


And this is coming from a guy that owns both of Yamaha's flag ship sleds!!!

I've ridden both as well, but jds800Rev has more time on the 4-TECH than I do.

The E-TECH will be significant lighter and less tiring in rough conditions, and better on fuel. But there is no denying the reliability and torque of a 4-Stroke!!! Plus the 4-TECH weighs about the same as a older REV 800 with electric start and it sounds like a muscle car.

I think it comes down to the type of riding you are going to do and how much you want to spend.
Charles
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 12:31 PM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!


You make some very good points and I agree with most of what you say. The reliability debate depends entirely on how well BRP has done their job. If they have enough electronics keeping track of all the important stuff, the engine should shut down before any damage occurs. As in your bad gas scenario, timing would be retarded until it will run without damage or shut down. Your old 800 did not have these failsafe electronics. As far as oil, the crank doesn't need much because there is no gas going into the crank to wash the oil away. There is probably more oil kicking around in the e-tec crank than in a regular 2-stroke. The indexed plugs are simply to get the flame of the spark directed right to the injector. No different than any other part that has to be in the right way.

There is no doubt about it, a 4-stroke is the safest, simplest way to get the job done, but that doesn't mean this e-tec cannot be succesful if it is done right. A 4-stroke isn't indistructable either and the extra weight is a concern, especially since it is carried so high. Do a casual roll over off a snowbank and see what happens to a 4-stroke. Blow a belt and over rev and listen to all those pretty valves going thru the piston tops.

Skidoo has alot riding on this new e-tec, especially since it has dropped the SDI for '09. It would be very foolish of them to have not done their homework. The 4-stroke sounds like an awsome engine as well and should be smooth and quiet. I think BRP is smart to cover all the angles. But I don't think I would go the 4-stroke way just because I was afraid of the e-tec. If you want a 4-stroke go for it, if you want a 2-stroke go for it. BRP has you covered. That's just plain smart business management. Hat's off to BRP!
GaderX
Go with the E-Tec. At 80 pounds lighter, its a no brainer. Get the two year warrantee and BRP back you if something happens.

If you plan on running the sled >10000 miles, get the four stroke.
treemax
QUOTE(GaderX @ Mar 15 2008, 07:48 PM) *
Go with the E-Tec. At 80 pounds lighter, its a no brainer. Get the two year warrantee and BRP back you if something happens.

If you plan on running the sled >10000 miles, get the four stroke.

I have 10,000 on my 05 600x sdi and it still rocks!!!
GaderX
Thats awesome... it seems more common now a days to see them last longer.
BlackStreak
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 11:31 AM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!
Don't take it personal... But... BS.. On the 4 strokes don't blow up.... Especially when you start modding...... Ive seen a couple of 4 strokers with the rods hanging out the sides...
lastcatgoingdoo
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 12:31 PM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!

lastcatgoingdoo
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 12:31 PM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!




two things have prevented me from joining the 4 stroke ranks, 1 is horsepower, the other is engine braking, what i have heard is the horsepower is there, tell me your thoughts on the engine braking onthe new 4 tec, thanks
Zippi
just got over 1000 miles on the new etec and i have to say im pretty impressed.
Scrimmer
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 6 2008, 12:31 PM) *
I've had the pleasure of riding both new doo's this year. The 4 stroke is the real deal!! It flat out rocks and makes the Etech feel slow. I thought the Etech felt no different than My 600 SDI. The 4 stroke felt way faster, quieter and smoother. As far as the oil thing goes you will spend about 40 bucks a season on a filter and oil change with the 4 stroke. Thats all I spend with My Apex. I have no idea what you will spend on the Etech.The thing about reliability is real and it has nothing to do with how long you plan on owning your sled. My 04 800 HO seized the first year I had it with 3100 miles on the odometer. The thing about the 4 stroke engines is they just don't fail. Its very plain and simple, they are rock solid reliable. You can be miles from home and put bad gas in your tank and your engine will still run while a 2 stroke will be burning holes in pisotns. This new Etech won't be anymore reliable than the 2 strokes Doo has now. I would also be very concerned with a lean running engine using very little oil. The 4 stroke engine will be easier to clutch and will run the same all the time. The new Etech I fear wil be very finicky when it comes to things like fuel quality. They even have special index plugs that must face a certain way or the engine will not run right. I'm so confident that the new 4 stroke will be better than the Etech that I'm going to order one tomorrow!!



QUOTE(lastcatgoingdoo @ Mar 16 2008, 08:54 PM) *
two things have prevented me from joining the 4 stroke ranks, 1 is horsepower, the other is engine braking, what i have heard is the horsepower is there, tell me your thoughts on the engine braking onthe new 4 tec, thanks

Just rode the 4Tech yesterday, not bad, good engine pull, but much preferred the ETech. The 4Tech had very harsh engine braking, never had to touch the brakes in corners, this when Yammy is trying to lessen their engine braking....If I were buying new, I'd be going with the 800R again, but if I were getting a replacement for the wife's SDI, it'd be the ETech!!!
GaderX
QUOTE(Scrimmer @ Mar 17 2008, 10:51 AM) *
Just rode the 4Tech yesterday, not bad, good engine pull, but much preferred the ETech. The 4Tech had very harsh engine braking, never had to touch the brakes in corners, this when Yammy is trying to lessen their engine braking....If I were buying new, I'd be going with the 800R again, but if I were getting a replacement for the wife's SDI, it'd be the ETech!!!



So you really like your 800R? I was thinking of upgrading to the 800 from my SDI, but I feel like going back to a Carbed sled would be worse...
Scrimmer
QUOTE(GaderX @ Mar 17 2008, 10:21 AM) *
So you really like your 800R? I was thinking of upgrading to the 800 from my SDI, but I feel like going back to a Carbed sled would be worse...

I was the same way last year, coming from the SDI to a carbed 800, but the thing absolutely rocks!! If you can hold off, there might be a 2010 800 Etech, but don't blame me if there isn't one, ok? If you like the 600 SDI, the 600 ETech absolutely rocks the SDI, the low end torque makes it feel like an 800R, not to mention it sips gas and oil, but for overall power, the 800R is still the better engine IMO. Good luck!!
TCAT1000
I had the pleasure of riding all of these yesterday and the 4-tec I rode rocked!! I think it was the most impressive sled I have rode to date- and I went there to ride the 800r, that 1200 didnt feel any heavier than the 800r and the motor brake was perfect I thaught- it felt as if the thing went into neutral when you let off it and it def has good pull, now the etec 600 is a slug!!!!! it sounds like an outboard motor when you hit the gas and takes a little bit to get up and going good, now if you dont need alot of speed or power this may be the sled to get,great gas mileage 21 -26 mpg and a qt of oil every 1000 miles and spark plugs go 6600 miles- ptetty cool , I am a cat guy thinking of buying rev and wanted the 800r as I have fast firecat but after riding the 4-tec Im torn!!!!!!!!
Sled-Ed
QUOTE(TCAT1000 @ Mar 22 2008, 09:37 AM) *
I had the pleasure of riding all of these yesterday and the 4-tec I rode rocked!! I think it was the most impressive sled I have rode to date- and I went there to ride the 800r, that 1200 didnt feel any heavier than the 800r and the motor brake was perfect I thaught- it felt as if the thing went into neutral when you let off it and it def has good pull, now the etec 600 is a slug!!!!! it sounds like an outboard motor when you hit the gas and takes a little bit to get up and going good, now if you dont need alot of speed or power this may be the sled to get,great gas mileage 21 -26 mpg and a qt of oil every 1000 miles and spark plugs go 6600 miles- ptetty cool , I am a cat guy thinking of buying rev and wanted the 800r as I have fast firecat but after riding the 4-tec Im torn!!!!!!!!


oh really, i just looked on the doo site and you can buy a e-tec TNT for under 10,000. Go to the yamaha nitro and you need 13000 canadian.
jds800Rev
QUOTE(Sled-Ed @ Mar 22 2008, 11:21 AM) *
oh really, i just looked on the doo site and you can buy a e-tec TNT for under 10,000. Go to the yamaha nitro and you need 13000 canadian.

Whats your point?? So you can buy a slug cheap!! The Nytro and the 1200 4 tech aren't slugs so they will cost more than a Etech.
BlackStreak
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 22 2008, 08:11 PM) *
Whats your point?? So you can buy a slug cheap!! The Nytro and the 1200 4 tech aren't slugs so they will cost more than a Etech.
Slug.... I have a 2 Riding Buddy's that I ride with every time I ride... 1 has a ETEC.. And 1 has a Nytro... And I have a 600 SDI... I guess the Nytro is a slug because whenever we all race we are all dead even... But in the deep powder we run all over the Nytro.... I rode all 3 machines... And Ill tell you.. You can keep that Nytro... It darts all over the place and It's a scary ride.. And it kind of harry in the corners... Why is this.. I know it's all about set up.. But When I got my XP it wasn't set up properly either.. And it wasn't all over the trail like the Nytro was
UnluckyDiablo
Havn't rode the 4-tec, but have rode the e-tec and I was very impressed. When they say light, boy do they mean it! Lot of fun to ride to, and my friend who own's a dealership (we went to college together) has verified at least 23 miles per gallon with the e-tec they sent him, sometimes more. I was one of those that said "if skidoo makes a 4 stroke and its reliable (basically, if its as good as their chassis), I'd have one. Well, they didn't, and I needed a new sled, so the nytro was the thing for me. However, had this 4 tec come out the same year as the nytro, I'd have had one hell of a decision on my hands as I feel the 4-tec fits the type of riding I've normally done. From what someone was saying, this isn't even a new engine for skidoo, they've been using it in their two seater sleds for a few years. Anyone confirm? If so, that should at least comfort some who are worried about them makeing a reliable 4 stroke. At 1200 cc, I imagine the 4tec engine breaks like a son of a gun. Also on oil, you're not using much on the 4-tec, and it has to be done once a year. Not a big deal in the least.

Blackstrreak, the guy who has the nytro clearly doesn't know how to set it up. I'm not saying he doesn't know about sledding, but I've barely touched the set up on mine and its much better than you discribe. Others have the same experience. So clearly more setup time is needed. They do dive in powder a bit, all that weight in the nose. I imagine the 4 tec may do the same thing, but in the nytros case, I think it has to do with the lousy skis, they just plain don't float and really bring it down. Sorry though, I've derailed from topic.

Just another perspective from some one who owns what they are clearly competeing with. Hope it helps.
Sled-Ed
QUOTE(UnluckyDiablo @ Mar 23 2008, 06:17 PM) *
Havn't rode the 4-tec, but have rode the e-tec and I was very impressed. When they say light, boy do they mean it! Lot of fun to ride to, and my friend who own's a dealership (we went to college together) has verified at least 23 miles per gallon with the e-tec they sent him, sometimes more. I was one of those that said "if skidoo makes a 4 stroke and its reliable (basically, if its as good as their chassis), I'd have one. Well, they didn't, and I needed a new sled, so the nytro was the thing for me. However, had this 4 tec come out the same year as the nytro, I'd have had one hell of a decision on my hands as I feel the 4-tec fits the type of riding I've normally done. From what someone was saying, this isn't even a new engine for skidoo, they've been using it in their two seater sleds for a few years. Anyone confirm? If so, that should at least comfort some who are worried about them makeing a reliable 4 stroke. At 1200 cc, I imagine the 4tec engine breaks like a son of a gun. Also on oil, you're not using much on the 4-tec, and it has to be done once a year. Not a big deal in the least.

Blackstrreak, the guy who has the nytro clearly doesn't know how to set it up. I'm not saying he doesn't know about sledding, but I've barely touched the set up on mine and its much better than you discribe. Others have the same experience. So clearly more setup time is needed. They do dive in powder a bit, all that weight in the nose. I imagine the 4 tec may do the same thing, but in the nytros case, I think it has to do with the lousy skis, they just plain don't float and really bring it down. Sorry though, I've derailed from topic.

Just another perspective from some one who owns what they are clearly competeing with. Hope it helps.

Nope this 1200 cc engine is out of their supercharged watercraft which makes 215 hp. This motor is 130hp NA

geez150
So what's the deal does this 600 e-tec have the power of other 600 class sleds or no??
peter
QUOTE(geez150 @ Mar 23 2008, 09:35 PM) *
So what's the deal does this 600 e-tec have the power of other 600 class sleds or no??



Seems many of the 09 TNT Etec's out there are very inconsistent. The one i rode DIDN"T feel like the SDI's ive owned...Not close, more like my wifes TNT.
Phoenix
I rode both sleds last Saturday @ a demo ride. I started out on the 1200, rode down the trail for a mile or two then switched sleds with a guy on the 600 e-tech and rode it back through the same stretch of trail. The 1200 was alot faster (the other guy said the same thing). The 600 e-tec I rode had a strange quirk I've never seen before. When letting off the throttle it coasted free (like normal), until it got down to 60 kph then it started slowing down, it felt like you were applying the brakes a little bit. When I got back I told the Doo guys about it and they took it out of service.

I was defenately impressed by the performance of the 1200 but I am leary about the reliability of the doos as I have heard of so many people having engine problems and then I ride one of their brand new sleds and it has something wrong with it. wall.gif
GaderX
How was the powerband of the 4Tec? Was it snappy all the way through? Any ski lift?
Phoenix
QUOTE(GaderX @ Mar 24 2008, 10:54 PM) *
How was the powerband of the 4Tec? Was it snappy all the way through? Any ski lift?


It pulled hard until I let off @ about 80mph or so...as far as ski lift I'm not sure because the trail was pretty icy and I didn't get off in the snow and do a take off from a stop to see what it would do...it never lifted the skis when I was riding down the trail though.
Charles
QUOTE(BlackStreak @ Mar 22 2008, 09:31 PM) *
Slug.... I have a 2 Riding Buddy's that I ride with every time I ride... 1 has a ETEC.. And 1 has a Nytro... And I have a 600 SDI... I guess the Nytro is a slug because whenever we all race we are all dead even... But in the deep powder we run all over the Nytro.... I rode all 3 machines... And Ill tell you.. You can keep that Nytro... It darts all over the place and It's a scary ride.. And it kind of harry in the corners... Why is this.. I know it's all about set up.. But When I got my XP it wasn't set up properly either.. And it wasn't all over the trail like the Nytro was


A little off topic, but I couldn't help but agree with you on the "Set Up" excuse. What Company would sell a machine that out of the crate is down right scrary and unsafe in the handling department? I own a sled from a Company that also needs ALOT of set up. My thoughts on this - I don't get paid to solve engineering problems for Companies that don't have their act together. Why not have the factory set it up, out of the crate, to go around corners. If for some demented reason I want it to do otherwise, I'll set that up!

SET UP. What a pile of CRAP!!
Nitrousman
QUOTE(UnluckyDiablo @ Mar 23 2008, 07:17 PM) *
Havn't rode the 4-tec, but have rode the e-tec and I was very impressed. When they say light, boy do they mean it! Lot of fun to ride to, and my friend who own's a dealership (we went to college together) has verified at least 23 miles per gallon with the e-tec they sent him, sometimes more. I was one of those that said "if skidoo makes a 4 stroke and its reliable (basically, if its as good as their chassis), I'd have one. Well, they didn't, and I needed a new sled, so the nytro was the thing for me. However, had this 4 tec come out the same year as the nytro, I'd have had one hell of a decision on my hands as I feel the 4-tec fits the type of riding I've normally done. From what someone was saying, this isn't even a new engine for skidoo, they've been using it in their two seater sleds for a few years. Anyone confirm? If so, that should at least comfort some who are worried about them makeing a reliable 4 stroke. At 1200 cc, I imagine the 4tec engine breaks like a son of a gun. Also on oil, you're not using much on the 4-tec, and it has to be done once a year. Not a big deal in the least.

Blackstrreak, the guy who has the nytro clearly doesn't know how to set it up. I'm not saying he doesn't know about sledding, but I've barely touched the set up on mine and its much better than you discribe. Others have the same experience. So clearly more setup time is needed. They do dive in powder a bit, all that weight in the nose. I imagine the 4 tec may do the same thing, but in the nytros case, I think it has to do with the lousy skis, they just plain don't float and really bring it down. Sorry though, I've derailed from topic.

Just another perspective from some one who owns what they are clearly competeing with. Hope it helps.


This is a brand new engine in the 4-Tec developed for the sled. They had a V-twin in the legend series for a while. This 4-Tec motor isn't out of one of the watercraft either and this was straight from the Doo reps mouth at the demo ride Saturday.
first4stroke
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 22 2008, 09:11 PM) *
Whats your point?? So you can buy a slug cheap!! The Nytro and the 1200 4 tech aren't slugs so they will cost more than a Etech.


So they aren't slugs but they are still a yamaha and a ski-doo, not a Four Stroke Arctic Cat the "Freaking flies riding two-up" Guess who?
jds800Rev
QUOTE(first4stroke @ Mar 26 2008, 08:53 PM) *
So they aren't slugs but they are still a yamaha and a ski-doo, not a Four Stroke Arctic Cat the "Freaking flies riding two-up" Guess who?


You just better be careful if you end up with a sled that goes over 40!! You can hurt yourself at those speeds! With your old sled you could be going wide open throttle, your Wife could fall off and jump back on without you ever taking your thimb off the throttle!
grggade
QUOTE(jds800Rev @ Mar 27 2008, 08:42 PM) *
You just better be careful if you end up with a sled that goes over 40!! You can hurt yourself at those speeds! With your old sled you could be going wide open throttle, your Wife could fall off and jump back on without you ever taking your thimb off the throttle!



Dang ,that was funny pointlaugh.gif
Mooselook
I have owned more than 20 cats and now own a 2008 Z1 SnoPro Nightfire......I rode both the e-tech and 1200 4 stroke three weeks ago.....and was so impressed with both that I am considering buying the etech for my wife and the 4 stroke renagade for myself. The e-tech was light, and responsive and very quick, although had trouble keeping the outside ski from lifting comming out of a hard corner on full throttle...suspension was awsome in 1 to 2 footers. The 4 stroke fealt a little heavier and steadier on the same 2 mile trail.....I was riding behind the factory rep and when I saw he took to the air of a six foot steep incline, I tried the same on the 4 stroke....the engine had a very quick snap and I was able to get 15 ft or more of air, and it landed sweet...the factory rep was looking over his shoulder as I was some 6 to 8 ft in the air...and when we got back to the coral he came over to me and said that was an awsome jump---and I said that was an awsome sled, I even went back the next day to try them again....Impressive.. both of them---that says a lot coming a 40 years of riding cats and nearly 100,000miles.
AllVipedUp
QUOTE(first4stroke @ Mar 26 2008, 08:53 PM) *
So they aren't slugs but they are still a yamaha and a ski-doo, not a Four Stroke Arctic Cat the "Freaking flies riding two-up" Guess who?




English................................Do you speak it?
Treebasher
QUOTE(Mooselook @ Apr 2 2008, 08:26 PM) *
I have owned more than 20 cats and now own a 2008 Z1 SnoPro Nightfire......I rode both the e-tech and 1200 4 stroke three weeks ago.....and was so impressed with both that I am considering buying the etech for my wife and the 4 stroke renagade for myself. The e-tech was light, and responsive and very quick, although had trouble keeping the outside ski from lifting comming out of a hard corner on full throttle...suspension was awsome in 1 to 2 footers. The 4 stroke fealt a little heavier and steadier on the same 2 mile trail.....I was riding behind the factory rep and when I saw he took to the air of a six foot steep incline, I tried the same on the 4 stroke....the engine had a very quick snap and I was able to get 15 ft or more of air, and it landed sweet...the factory rep was looking over his shoulder as I was some 6 to 8 ft in the air...and when we got back to the coral he came over to me and said that was an awsome jump---and I said that was an awsome sled, I even went back the next day to try them again....Impressive.. both of them---that says a lot coming a 40 years of riding cats and nearly 100,000miles.


You'll have to let us know how THE Z1 goes! A lot of great options this year!
edge900
top
The budz
QUOTE(edge900 @ Oct 6 2008, 09:28 PM) *
top


wtf.gif you brought back a thread that was dead since April and you just write "top"? What the hell man?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.